DriveTime Vs. CarMax: Key Differences Between Two Major Used Car Retailers (2024)

When it comes time to buy a used car, two major national chains likely come to mind – DriveTime and CarMax. As leading used vehicle retailers, DriveTime and CarMax have each carved out a significant share of the market, but they have some notable differences in their business models and car buying experiences.

This comprehensive guide examines the key features, pros, cons and frequently asked questions when it comes to DriveTime and CarMax to help consumers make an informed decision.

A Brief Comparison Table

FeatureDriveTimeCarMax
PricingPosted prices, room for negotiationNo haggle pricing
SelectionThousands of used vehicles50,000+ used vehicle inventory
FinancingSpecializes in bad credit, in-house financingPartner lender financing only
Test DrivesStandard test drives24-hour test drives
Returns7-day money back guarantee30-day money back returns
Online ExperienceFull online purchasing availableOnline tools to aid shopping

Overview of DriveTime

Founded in 2002 and headquartered in Tempe, Arizona, DriveTime has emerged as one of the largest used car chains in the nation with over 145 dealership locations across the country. DriveTime prides itself on offering a large selection of used vehicles from various manufacturers, flexible financing options and a customer-friendly car buying process.

DriveTime Vs. CarMax: Key Differences Between Two Major Used Car Retailers (1)

Some key things to know about DriveTime:

  • Specializes in used cars, SUVs., trucks and vans typically between 1-5 years old with reasonable mileage.
  • Vast nationwide inventory with thousands of vehicles, updated daily online.
  • In-house financing available for customers, including no credit check options.
  • accepts trade-ins and most vehicles come with a limited warranty.
  • 7-day money back guarantee if not fully satisfied.
  • DriveTime Express offers customers a way to browse and purchase vehicles completely online and have them delivered.

Overview of CarMax

Headquartered in Richmond, Virginia, CarMax pioneered the “no haggle” used car buying experience when it was founded in 1993. With over 200 locations across the U.S., CarMax advertises a huge selection, low pricing and customer-oriented sales process.

Here are some of CarMax’s notable features:

  • Extensive nationwide inventory of over 50,000 used cars, trucks, vans and SUVs. both online and on lots.
  • Prices are fixed and clearly marked on all vehicles. No negotiations or haggling.
  • Financing, trade-ins, warranties and protection plans available.
  • Offers a 24-hour test drive policy and 30-day money back returns.
  • Online tools like the car buying assistant provides personalized recommendations.
  • Home delivery now available in many areas of the country.

Also Read: Comparison Between CarMax And Enterprise Car Sales

Key Differences Between DriveTime and CarMax

Now that we’ve outlined the basics of each company, let’s directly compare some of the major differences between the DriveTime and CarMax car buying experiences:

  • Pricing

At DriveTime, prices are clearly posted online and on vehicles, but there is often still room for negotiation. Sales associates may be willing to come down on price if asked. CarMax takes the opposite approach with strict no haggle pricing that can’t be negotiated.

  • Selection

Both offer extensive nationwide inventories, but CarMax typically has a wider selection with over 50,000 vehicles across their locations compared to DriveTime’s thousands of cars. CarMax locations also tend to be larger.

  • Financing

DriveTime specializes in flexible in-house financing and works with customers having poor/no credit. Rates can be high, so shop around. CarMax offers financing through partner lenders but doesn’t emphasize it as much. Rates are dependent on credit.

  • Test Drives

CarMax has a 24-hour test drive policy compared to DriveTime’s more normal test drives. This gives CarMax customers extra time to try out vehicles.

  • Returns

DriveTime touts a 7-day money back guarantee if not satisfied. CarMax gives customers 30 days to return a vehicle for any reason. Both show confidence in their vehicles.

  • Online Experience

DriveTime Express allows complete online car buying from home while CarMax focuses more on using online tools to aid shopping before visiting a store. DriveTime also lacks the personalized recommendations and assistant CarMax offers.

Also Watch This Review Video:

Pros of DriveTime

What are the major advantages of buying from DriveTime Vs. competitors?

  • Specializes in customers with less than perfect credit with flexible financing options and programs available. Makes financing more accessible.
  • Great selection of lightly used vehicles between 1-5 years old, many with reasonably low mileage and plenty of life left.
  • DriveTime Express online car buying experience provides convenience and saves time for savvy customers.
  • Clear pricing posted on vehicles gives buyers a reference point to start negotiations if desired.
  • Locations across the country make browsing inventory and test driving easy.
  • Money back guarantee provides consumer confidence and peace of mind in major purchase.

Cons of DriveTime

Some potential downsides of buying from DriveTime include:

  • While posted, prices aren’t fixed so negotiating may be necessary to get the best deal. Can create back and forth.
  • Interest rates through in-house financing tend to be higher than financing from an outside bank or credit union.
  • Selection less robust than the nation’s largest used retailers like CarMax. Limited mostly to popular makes and models.
  • No extended test drive policy like some competitors. Test drives can be short and rushed.
  • Online vehicle descriptions and photos often lacking details buyers want to see. Reliance on visiting store.
  • Some customer complaints about high-pressure sales tactics from representatives.

Pros of CarMax

What makes CarMax a compelling option Vs. other used car retailers?

DriveTime Vs. CarMax: Key Differences Between Two Major Used Car Retailers (2)
  • Massive selection with varied makes, models, colors and options. Great for finding something very specific.
  • Strict no haggle pricing provides a low stress buying experience without tedious negotiations.
  • Financing rates through partner lenders are competitive based on buyer’s credit. Pre-approvals available.
  • Generous 24-hour test drive policy gives customers extra time to properly try out vehicles.
  • 30-day money back guarantee, even better than DriveTime’s return policy.
  • Personalized online tools and assistant make searching inventory and budgeting easier.
  • Home delivery in many areas adds convenience for buyers who prefer it.

Cons of CarMax

Possible disadvantages of CarMax to consider include:

  • While prices are transparent, the no haggle policy means no ability to negotiate or get a lower price.
  • Costs can run higher than smaller independent used lots. Condition and selection comes with premium pricing.
  • Emphasis is more on self service online or in store. Sales staff provide little guidance unless asked.
  • No special financing programs for customers with bad credit. Must have solid credit to qualify for partner loan terms.
  • Locations are large retailer-style facilities. Lacks personal touch of small car lots.
  • Some customers report pushy associates trying to upsell add-ons and services after a purchase is made.

Also Read: Comparison Between Carvana And DriveTime

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Does DriveTime use trackers?

Yes, most vehicles purchased from DriveTime have GPS trackers installed. This allows DriveTime to disable the vehicle remotely in case of missed payments. The trackers are supposed to be removed upon completion of the finance contract.

Does DriveTime have return policy?

Yes, DriveTime offers a 7-day money back return policy if not fully satisfied with the vehicle for any reason. The car must be returned in similar condition with limited mileage put on it. Any down payment or payments made are refunded back to the buyer under this policy.

What questions to ask CarMax?

When buying from CarMax, make sure to ask: Does the price listed reflect the full out-the-door price including all fees and taxes? Is this vehicle a CarMax retail unit or from the wholesale auction? Retail cars tend to be higher quality. Does this vehicle have any remaining manufacturer warranty or aftermarket warranty coverage? What reconditioning and inspections has this vehicle passed?Is there any damage, repairs or re-painting that I should know about? How long has this vehicle been in your inventory? Quick turnover can reflect demand.

What is CarMax strategy?

CarMax aims to take the stress and haggling out of car buying. They achieve this through offering fixed, no-negotiation pricing, a huge selection of popular vehicles, flexible financing terms for qualified buyers, extended test drives and longer money back guarantees. This transparent and customer-focused approach is part of their “Love Your Car” strategy to improve the car shopping experience.

The Bottom Line

When comparing DriveTime and CarMax, it’s clear both have their own strengths and weaknesses that will appeal to different buyers.

DriveTime specializes more in flexible financing and serving budget-minded customers, even those with poor credit. CarMax focuses on top-notch selection, strict pricing and a low pressure sales process.

Do you want to negotiate and find financing help despite bad credit? DriveTime might be a fit. Are you willing to pay more for a vast selection and haggle-free experience? CarMax could be right for you.

For most buyers, visiting locations of both chains, taking extended test drives and comparing options side-by-side will help determine if DriveTime or CarMax is the better choice.

With large national presences, you can’t go wrong taking the time to shop both when buying your next used car.

DriveTime Vs. CarMax: Key Differences Between Two Major Used Car Retailers (2024)

FAQs

What makes DriveTime different? ›

The DriveTime car buying experience is unique because we put the process in your hands. We allow you to dictate how the sales process will unfold. We first ask if you would prefer to get approved for a loan first or view our inventory to find a vehicle perfectly matched for you.

What makes CarMax different? ›

CarMax has a no-haggle policy, which means you can't negotiate the price. This can be a benefit, though, because you know you're getting CarMax's best rate first instead of a lowball offer. You can still sell your car to CarMax after the seven-day period, but you'll need to get a new offer.

Are CarMax and DriveTime the same? ›

Large used-car retailers like CarMax and DriveTime function like independent dealerships, but they're different for a number of reasons. For example, CarMax calls for inspections of all of its cars for sale, and each comes with a free vehicle history report and safety recall report. DriveTime's program is similar.

What are the benefits of buying from DriveTime? ›

What are the main benefits of buying a used car from DriveTime? DriveTime vehicles include several benefits to help give you peace of mind. Each vehicle includes an AutoCheck ® history report, a 30 day/1,500 mile limited warranty, and 5 Day Return Guarantee. We also have optional extended vehicle coverage available.

Are DriveTime and Carvana the same? ›

Carvana. In 2013, DriveTime became the majority owner of Carvana; the two companies are operated completely separately. Carvana was founded in 2012 and launched nationwide in November 2013. The Phoenix-based company is an online used car retailer.

Does DriveTime have high interest rates? ›

Estimated monthly payments shown assume that a customer is purchasing a vehicle for personal use with DriveTime's average term of 71 monthly payments and an APR (interest rate) of either 7% (best deal) or 22.6% (average deal), based upon DriveTime transactions January 2023-September 2023.

What are the weaknesses of CarMax? ›

This dependence on economic conditions is a weakness as it introduces uncertainty and potential instability into CarMax's business model. Market Share Concentration Risks: While CarMax is the largest used-vehicle retailer in the U.S., its market share of vehicles 0-10 years old is estimated at only around 4%.

Why to not use CarMax? ›

Is CarMax really good? CarMax is good for people who want better warranties and higher-quality used vehicles. However, CarMax's prices are typically higher than used car dealerships, which might make it a non-starter for frugal car shoppers.

What is CarMax competitive advantage? ›

The following competitive advantages help CarMax grow its market share over the long term: Largest and most profitable firm in its industry. Omni channel sales process that meets varied online and brick-and-mortar/test drive needs. Inventory and cost advantages from its wholesale business.

What is similar to DriveTime? ›

The closest competitor to drivetime.com are vroom.com and enterprisecarsales.com. To understand more about drivetime.com and its competitors, sign up for a free account to explore Semrush's Traffic Analytics and Market Explorer tools.

Who competes with DriveTime? ›

DriveTime | Bridgecrest | SilverRock competitors include Elevate, Ally Financial Inc., Capital One, Goldman Sachs and Carvana.

Are prices negotiable at DriveTime? ›

We won't hassle you; our customer experience guides are here to help answer any and all questions that you may have. We also offer no-haggle pricing, which means you won't spend hours at the dealership dealing with the stressful negotiation process.

Do DriveTime cars have trackers? ›

Inilex's GPS device, about the size of a deck of cards, is installed on vehicles for tracking purposes.

How does DriveTime make money? ›

DriveTime, which sells used cars and is in the sometimes-controversial business of making auto loans to low-income consumers, has seen its business grow 19% annually in the last decade. With shares of Carvana up 46% since its April IPO, Garcia's stake in Carvana alone is worth $1.5 billion.

What is proof of income for DriveTime? ›

Proof of income is a document, form, or written statement (or combination of these documents) that proves how much money you make and your current financial status. Usually this proof is in the form of a current bank statement or pay stub. Proof of income is required when purchasing a vehicle from a dealership.

Can you negotiate with DriveTime? ›

No-Haggle Pricing Limits Negotiating

Fortunately, online tools can help you estimate the value of a vehicle based on its make, model, condition, mileage, and other factors, allowing you to see if the price listed by DriveTime is fair.

Does DriveTime put trackers on cars? ›

PHOENIX — Drive Time announced it has selected Inilex to be the supplier of GPS-based vehicle tracking and recovery solutions for its 89 dealership locations.

Is DriveTime a predatory lender? ›

CFPB took action against a “buy-here, pay-here” car dealer. DriveTime must pay $8,000,000 as a civil money penalty, end its unfair debt collection tactics, fix its credit reporting practices, and arrange for harmed consumers to obtain free credit reports.

References

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Recommended Articles
Article information

Author: Moshe Kshlerin

Last Updated:

Views: 5972

Rating: 4.7 / 5 (77 voted)

Reviews: 92% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Moshe Kshlerin

Birthday: 1994-01-25

Address: Suite 609 315 Lupita Unions, Ronnieburgh, MI 62697

Phone: +2424755286529

Job: District Education Designer

Hobby: Yoga, Gunsmithing, Singing, 3D printing, Nordic skating, Soapmaking, Juggling

Introduction: My name is Moshe Kshlerin, I am a gleaming, attractive, outstanding, pleasant, delightful, outstanding, famous person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.